Dr.Barry Kelleher and Dr.John Crowe say hereditary haemochromatosis
is the most common cause of iron overload, and the highest frequency
in the world has been identified in Ireland.
Disorders of iron metabolism, particularly of iron deficiency, arre
well recognized throughout the world.
However with increasing affluence in the Western World , diseases associated
with iron overload are becoming a greater health burden. Hereditary
haemochromatosis (HH) is the commonest cause worldwide and also the
best characterized.
The first description of the disease was by Trousseau in 1865 when he
described the clinical triad of glycourea, hepatic cirrhosis and hyper-pigmentation
of the skin. Von Recklinghausen recognied that these features were caused
by excessive iron deposition and coined the term haemochromatosis 25
years later. Since these original descriptions, HH has been recognized
as an autosonal recessive condition defined in 2000 by the European
Association for the Study of the Liver (EASL) in its consensus statement
as" an inherited disorder resulting from an inborn error of iron
metabolism which leads to progressive iron loading of parenchymal cells
in the liver, pancreas and heart. In its fully developed stage , organ
structure and function are impaired."
Genetic aspects
Two genetic mutations of the haemochromatosis gene (HFE) were discovered
by Feder et al . in 1996 - C282Y and H63D. Iron overload is associated
with C282Y homozgosity and to a lesser extent with C282Y/H63D compound
heterozygosity.
How these mutations precipitate iron overloading is not fully understood
but it is known that they cause a structural change within the HFE protein.
This is postulated to result in failure of the duodenal enterocyte to
recognize that circulating iron stores are adequate and subsequently
in upregulation of its iron absorbtive capacity. Previous population
screening studies have consistently shown a very high prevelance of
haemochromatosis of between 1 in 300 and I in 400 in Caucasian populations.
With the advent of genetic testing , the numbers with susceptibility
to iron overload are even greater than expected. It is no surprize,
due to the genetic homoheneity of the Irsh population and their Celtic
origin, that the highest frequency of C282Y alleles worldwide has been
reported in the Irish population.
Results recently published reveal that 1: 83 of the population are C282Y
homozygous, 1:25 are C282Y/H63D compound heterozygous and 1: 5 are C282Y
heterozygous i.e. 1: 20 of the Irish population, have the genetic susceptibility
to develop significant iron overload.
Presentation
In general, the severity of the clinical illness is related to the iron
burden. The clinical condition evolves in a series of stages beginning
with
* clinically insignificant iron accumulation (0-20 years/O-5g iron
storage).
* iron overload without disease (approximately 20-40 yers/ 10-20g iron
storage)
*iron overload with organ damage (greater than 40 yeare/ greater than
20g iron storage).
Fatigue is the commonest symptom affecting up to 60% of patients but
is often associated with degrees of iron overload below the threshold
fo organ damage.The remaining common symptoms and signs in the developed
syndrome are as follows:
1. Sexual dysfunction (10-40 per cent).
2. Arthralgias/arthritis 30-40 per cent).
3. Hepatomegaly /cirrhosis (22-60 per cent).
4. Diabetis mellitus (10-30 percent).
5. Cardiac failure (15-35 per cent).
The outline above suggesting simple step-wise progression of iron overload
overlooks one of the most frustrating aspects of dealing with this disease-
that of phenotypic variability.. Of those that are C282Y homozygous,
approximately 60 per cent will develop iron overload sufficient to cause
organ damage and reports suggest that figure is between 2-20 percent
in C282y/H63D compound heterozygotes. The remainder, despite their genetic
predisposition to excessive iron loading will not accumulate iron sufficient
to cause end organ damage.
The factors that influence this variability are incompletely understood.Menstrual
blood loss is one well recognized contributing factor but other enviornmental
influences such as diet and alcohol contribute to the severity of disease
prresentation. However, these factors do not fully explain the wide
spectrum of disease manifestations and it is felt that mutations of
other iron transport ,as yet unidentified, may contribute.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis of HH is based on biochemical evidence of irnoverload,
viz. high fasting serum iron , a positive genetic gest and where indicated
liver histology.
Our recommendations for the Irish population are as recommended by the
practice guidelines of the American Association for the Study of Liver
Disease (AASLD).
|
SYMPTOMATIC
Unexplained manifestations of
liver disease indices
Type
11 diabetes mellitus
Atypical
cardiac disease
Early onset sexual dysfunction
Early onset atypical arthropathy
|
ASYMPTOMATIC
Individuals with unexplained
elevation of iron
Unexplained
elevation of
liver enzymes
|
Recommendations
Fasting
transferrin saturation (TS) and serum ferritin

+ve
TS > 45% * / ferritin elevated

Genotype
testing
FAMILY
SCREENING
Recommendations
First
degree relative of confirmed case of confirmed case of HH

Direct
genotype testing
____________________
Children of confirmed case of HH

Genetic
testing of the spouse:-
If negative no need to screen children:
If carrier (C282Y or H63D) further genetic testing
of children is indicated in those aged > 20
* Transferrin saturation may be unreliable if there has been
recent blood loss.
|
Caution with respect to use of widespread screening , amongst extended
families, in particular young children, is warrented. The potential
impact of genetic discrimination and needless anxiety in th paediatric
population should be avoided. Given the fact that there is no disease
impact in young patients, we advocate screening of adults only when
each individual can consent for the test and take responsibility for
its result.
Prioe to the commencment of therapeutic phlebotomy, some patients may
require liver biopsy to estimate the degree of fibrosis or cirrhosis.The
presence of cirrhosis statifies those at risk from complications of
chronic liver disease (varices, ascites ) but, more importantly , highlights
those at rish from hepatocellular carcinoma. Due to the invasive nature
of the procedure, biops is recommended for those likely to have significant
hapatic damage. This can be predicted from the presence of one or more
of the following clinical/biochemical factors:
* age greater than 40
* abnormal transaminases
*Ferritin greater than 1000
Discretion is appropriate in recommending liver biopsy on the basis
of age alone. In the absence oif the above indications of cirrhosis,
other risk factors ( alcohol abuse or coexisting clinical features of
HH ) may play a role in making this recommendation.
Treatment
Phlebotomy is the cornerstone of treatment and, given its simplicity,
is likely to remain so for the foreseeable future. Certain clinical
features may be ameliarated by phlebotomy (malais, fatigue, skin pigmentation,
insulin requirements, abdominal pain)., whereas other features are either
less responsive to iron removal or do not respond at all ( arthropothy,
hypogonadism, cirrhosis).
Therapeutic phlebotomy of 400-500ml once or twice a week as tolerated.
Each venisection should be preceded by measurement of haemoglobin to
avoid iatrogenic anaemia. Ferratin is a reliable indicator during therapeutic
phlebotomy and once patients are nearing iron depletion, a goal of serum
ferritin less than 50 mg/l
indicated iron depletion.
Maintenance phlebotomy must be tailored for each patient by six monthly
monitoring of fasting serum transferrin and ferritin levels.The factors
that influence aggressive loading following iron depletion are not fully
understood but phlebotomy therapy itself, by stimulating erythropoiesis
is felt to contribute to increasing iron absorption.
Strict iron deficient diet is not recommended but iron rich foods sgould
be avoided or consumed in modertion. Iron and Vitamin C supplements
should be avoided. Tea drinking is benificial but to make significant
impact,large volumes must be consumed, although in a nation of tea drinkers
this is often achieved without effort.
trreatment must also include surveillance for hepatocellular carcinoma
(HHC). HH patients with cirrhosis have the highest relative risk of
HHC known (>200 ) and in early reports, before surveillance was commonplace,
it was responsible for about 30 per cent of HH deaths.
Despite these figures there are no data on the optimal method, frequency
or cost effectiveness for surveillance of HHC. In light of thism most
institutions advocate what is practical and we rrecommend annual liver
ultrasound and estimation of serum alpha-feta-protein levels every six
months. Surveillance in those without cirrhosis is not warrented but
in light of several reports of HHC in this cohort, extra vigilance does
seem prudent.
Screening
No other aspect of HH is more hotly debated than the question of screening.
The central question relates to whether the benefits of screening outweigh
the costs to a sufficient degree to justify general screening on public
health grounds.The general principles of screening for any disease within
a population must be considered. In Ireland, for example, HH is common
(five per cent of population is genetically predisposed) , easily treated
and can be deteted at a preclinical stage, suggesting that it may be
an ideal candidate for population screening.
Arguements against highlight the unpredictable course in many and the
prohibitive cost benefit. As the costs of genetic testing continue to
fall, the likelihood of population screening in areas of increased prevalence
of the specific mutations is high.
Future directions
Research in the area of iron metabolism has exploded since the discovery
of the gene in 1996 but, as with many discoveries, it has opened the
door on many as yet unanswered questions. Areas of active research include
* identification of major and minor disease modifiers
*determine the effect of C282Y and H63D mutations in
contributing to other liver diseases
*The contribution of HH to the diabetic health burden
*the most effective method of population screening.
References are availavle on request.
Dr. Barry Kelleher MB MRCPI Registrar in Gastroenterology,
Dr.John Crowe, Ph.D. FRCPI, Consultant Gastroenterologist/Hepatologist,Centre
for Liver Disease, Mater Miseracordiae Hospital,Dublin 7.